The Cooper Institute
 

Founded in 1970 by the "Father of Aerobics"
Kenneth H. Cooper MD, MPH

Loading
 
 

The Alkaline Diet: Help or Hype?

Posted in
Eat better

Tuesday, Nov 01, 2016

As Americans, we often take our many liberties for granted. For example, the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution guarantees all of us the right of free speech. This privilege applies not only to the spoken word, but also to printed materials such as books and websites. Thus, anyone can write a diet book or have a nutrition website and say pretty much whatever they please. You may be surprised to learn that many of the best-selling diet books over the past few decades have been written by individuals who have little or no formal training in nutrition. During this time, rates of obesity have skyrocketed worldwide; which would strongly suggest that most of these diets do not result in long-term weight control.

Because there are an endless number of diet programs available, one must have a gimmick in order for their diet to stand out from all the rest. For example, one diet might urge us to ‘eat like a caveman’, while another may emphasize avoiding high glycemic index or processed foods.  One of the latest fads is the Alkaline Diet. This approach is based on the acid/alkali opinion regarding disease. When our body breaks down the foods we eat, the waste products are sometimes called ‘ash.’ The ash can either be acidic or alkaline. The pitch is that by consuming more foods that produce alkaline ash and fewer foods that produce acidic ash, you can change the pH of your body. This in turn will lead to weight loss, increased energy, and a decreased risk of chronic conditions such as cancer, arthritis, osteoporosis, kidney and gall stones, etc. This reminds me of a wise old saying: “If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is!”

Before we continue, let’s talk a little chemistry. The pH continuum is a numerical scale between 0 and 14. Numbers at the lower end of the scale indicate strong acids, while numbers at the upper end represent strong bases (alkaline).  For example, water has a pH of 7, which is neutral (neither acidic nor alkaline). It is important to note that pH levels vary throughout the body.  Blood normally has a pH of 7.4, while the pH of muscle tissue is about 7.2.  Bile and pancreatic juices typically have a pH of about 8.0, while our stomach is always very acidic with a pH of approximately 2.0. This is because the stomach produces hydrochloric acid, which helps to break down food during the digestive process. None of these pH values is the least bit controversial; in fact you will find this information in all standard medical textbooks. It is also reasonable to state that some foods are more on the acidic ash-producing end of the continuum, while other foods are more alkaline. For example, fruit juice, soda, coffee, nuts, dairy, pasta, rice, other grains, alcohol, chocolate, beans, and meat/fish/poultry are somewhat acidic. Conversely, plant-based foods such as some fruits and vegetables tend to be more alkaline.

The major premise behind the Alkaline Diet is that our body is too acidic because we consume too many acidic ash-producing foods, and that this condition increases the risk of chronic disease. By limiting acidic foods and emphasizing alkaline foods, proponents of the diet claim that this shift will make the body less acidic, which will in turn decrease the risk of disease. In particular, the Alkaline Diet claims to change the pH of the blood. At this point, I will have to scream “Whoa Nellie!”  One of the major functions of the kidneys is to regulate the acid-base balance of the body. This includes keeping blood pH at a constant level of 7.4. Despite what proponents of the diet claim, there is not a speck of scientific evidence that what you eat or drink will change the pH of your blood (or anything else in your body). Another fallacy of this diet is that you can test your body’s pH by testing the pH of your urine. Any board-certified urologist will tell you that the pH of urine is not an indicator of pH in the rest of your body. Regardless of the pH of your urine, if your kidneys are functioning normally, the pH of your blood will always be 7.4.  In fact, any licensed health care professional will tell you that a significant deviation from this number is lethal!

At this point, you may be wondering about the effects of the Alkaline Diet on weight loss.  Here’s where the gimmick comes into play.  By limiting the countless ‘acidic-forming’ foods in your diet, and by eating more ‘alkaline-forming’ fruits and vegetables, you will automatically cut down on calorie intake.  Guess what happens when you cut down on calories?  You lose weight!  The problem is that by limiting or eliminating so many foods, we are missing out on a wealth of essential nutrients. I’d be the first to agree that people should cut back on soda, energy drinks, and some of the other junk foods that exist closer to the acidic end of the continuum.  However, other somewhat acidic foods such as lean meats, fish, low-fat dairy, beans, and whole grains are great sources of protein, vitamins, and minerals. Plus, don’t forget about all the fiber and antioxidants in beans and whole grains, and those beneficial omega-3’s in fatty fish!

Another big problem with the Alkaline Diet is that it pretty much ignores the concept of regular exercise for good health and weight control.  We have known for decades that diet by itself is simply not very effective for long-term weight control, and that regular exercise along with a prudent reduced-calorie diet is much more likely to result in long-term weight control than either one by itself.

“But wait!” you say. Isn’t there proof that the Alkaline Diet prevents cancer and a host of other diseases? Actually, there is no proof whatsoever! If there was proof, it would be the lead story on the national news, on the front page of every newspaper, and be featured prominently on the American Cancer Society, American Diabetes Association, and American Heart Association websites. If you are a conspiracy theorist and think that ‘they’ are trying to hide this information, I would tell you that being a conspiracy theorist is pretty much a useless hobby.    

I view most popular diets the same way that I view most politicians. They tend to overpromise and under deliver. So, when a diet sounds too good to be true, it’s wise to be skeptical. An endorsement from a Hollywood celebrity is not exactly good science. We would do well to follow the current public health guidelines for dietary intake: Consume more fruits, vegetables, legumes (beans and peas), whole grains, low-fat dairy (or fortified soy), raw nuts, and fatty fish.  Consume less simple sugar, saturated fat, trans fat, and sodium; and be sure to get at least 150 minutes per week of moderate intensity aerobic exercise. Don’t forget to do your strength training at least twice a week as well!